Monday, December 9, 2019

Chicago Police and Cook County State's Attorney Release Hunter Best File After Dropping Several Felonies Against Best, Who Sexually Abused Two Young Girls

Hunter Best, Chicago Police Photo

Hunter is his name, and a hunter is what he became. Chicago Police were alerted to the recently convicted Hunter Best when he literally went on the hunt in the upscale Lincoln Park neighborhood of Chicago. The original charges he faced were one felony count of aggravated criminal sexual abuse, felony criminal trespass to residence, misdemeanor battery and Class X felony home invasion. The initial arrest information in the graphic below shows the limited information about their arrest of Hunter Best.

Hunter Best arrest information taken from the Chicago Police Adult Arrest Database online
This offender committed his crimes on May 27th, 2018 when he attacked two female children in two separate homes located close to one block apart. His first victim was a 13 year-old girl in the 400 block of west Belden, and his second female child victim was in the 500 block of west Grant. His 2nd victim was 11 years-old at the time he committed his offense.

Area Central Detectives were assigned and later released video of this offender in two separate locations near where his offenses occurred. Detectives gave a physical description of this offender as a white male between 20 and 30 years-old with a light complexion, short brown or strawberry blonde hair, 5’7”, weighing possibly 160 pounds wearing a light-colored button-down shirt, sleeves rolled up, slim-type dark pants, and wearing white gym shoes. Detectives told the public they knew him to be a smoker.

By June 18th, 2018, the Cook County Circuit Court issued an arrest warrant for this offender. Hunter Best recently plead guilty in this case, resulting in the Cook County State's Attorney's Office dropping 26 felony charges, plus other felonies against this offender for a total of 44 felony charges dropped. Those charges included four counts of Class X felony home invasion involving a sex offense. The state also dropped 14 burglary counts and four sex-related charges.

Evidence collection from one crime scene this offender was at yielded an empty beer can and a cigarette, which prosecutors in this case said he could not be excluded from because a DNA profile showed only one out of 6.5 quintillion unrelated people would be a match.

The following record numbers will assist the public, and other properly interested parties to locate and obtain records relating to Hunter Best:

CPD RD Numbers JB-280701 and JB-281084

CPD Central Booking Number (CB#): 19674224

Date of Birth: 12/18/1992

ISB#: 36159131


Illinois Dept of Corrections Inmate#: Y39525

Mittimus: 2018CR107370, 107360

 What The Investigative Case File Reveals

Chicago-One performed a Freedom of Information Act Request with Chicago Police, and the Cook County State's Attorney's Office, obtaining their records to find out why this offender was offered a sweet plea agreement, and how the investigation was carried out.

CWB Chicago reported the plea agreement between Hunter Best and the Cook County State's Attorney on behalf of the people of the State of Illinois on October 30th, 2019. 

This case has two Chicago Police RD numbers associated with it, and two Chicago OEMC event numbers. The first case report was filed on 27 May 2018 after a 911 call made at or around 8AM that morning. The Beat of Occurrence was 1811, and the reporting officer on CPD Beat of Assignment 1812 (paper car) arrived at 9AM, according to the case report under RD# JB-280701 with Event# 1814705466, Case ID# 11327969. Dual UCR codes assigned for two simultaneous offenses as 1365 (Criminal Trespass to Residence) and 1563 (Sex Offense - Criminal Sexual Abuse)

The second was  RD# JB-281084 filed around 4PM on the same date as the first report.

CPD personnel assigned to RD# JB-280701 with Event# 05466

Detective L. Bond - Star# 21240 (Independent Administrator, photo array presented at Unit 079 on 29 May 18)

CPD Evidence Technician T. McKitterick - Star# 18546, Beat 5814 also assigned. This E.T. created crime scene report# 368957 (Metal cigarette box) 27 May 2018

CPD made an error as to Detective beat assignment. The 51xx series is Area South. This was an Area Central investigation. The proper detective beat series is 52xx. Detective Schmit is actually beat 5261A, which is a team of Detectives, hence the letter "A" at the end of the beat number.

Detective Schmit was assigned this case on 27 May 2018 by Sgt Sullivan - Star# 2632, at 5:45PM. Schmit then carried-out his investigation which started with a review of the original case report. In the process of his investigation, Schmit then learns that 018th District Sgt. Vogt - Star# 845, received new information that Schmit should be aware of. This brings Schmit to 018 where he meets with Sgt. Vogt. Schmit then learns before he was assigned this investigation, 018 had a second report of a Criminal Sexual Assault. This new information comes about due to the astute observations of a Chicago OEMC Police Dispatcher on the 2nd Watch.

The investigative file for this first of two reports involving the same offender lists the following recovered and inventoried evidence

The beer can was re-inventoried by Sgt. Vogt under inventory# 14181262, and the same Sgt. also re-inventoried a cigarette butt under inventory# 14181253. Sgt. Vogt hand-carried these items to Forensic Services, per report of Det. Schmidt.

On 29 May 2018, beer can and whole cigarette submitted to Illinois State Police for DNA testing on ISP Request Form# 76202.

Victim interviews with adult victims were conducted on 27 May 2018 at 9:40PM at the residence for victim-1, in RD# JB-280701, and 28 May 2018 with adult victim-2 at 4:15PM at the residence in RD# JB-281084.

Child victim-sensitive interview was carried-out at the Chicago Children's Advocacy Center (CCAC) / CPD Unit 079 on 29 May 2018 at 7PM for child victim-1, and 01 June 2018 at 9AM for child victim-2.

Cook County ASA Susie Bucaro witnessed the forensic interview of child victim-1 on 29 May 2018. Det. Schmit was also present as a witness. This was when things start falling apart for the offender in this case, as Det Schmit makes a one-line statement showing the child's version of events matches the parent's version of events.

Area Central Detective Division Releases Community Alerts

Through due-dilligence and the help of a local property management company, Detective Schmit obtains useful evidence from video camera systems that allows him to update an earlier version of an Area Central Detective Division Community Alert.

 NBC 5 Chicago covered the community alerts of May 30th the next day on May 31st, 2018. 

 Area Central Investigation Continues

Area Central Detectives weren't done yet, they weren't sitting around waiting for tips to flood their phone lines. These Detectives know that cooperation with police in the community is rare, only occurring when those who cooperate have incentive to do so.

On May 31st, Detectives continue chasing leads. An attorney for one person contacts Det. Schmit and informs him that video footage he sent multiple requests for could be picked-up later that day. Schmit then gets a call from a husband and wife saying they're "99%" certain "this is the offender" in reference to seeing the person of interest photos on the news. Detective W. Johnson - Star# 20169, gathered video footage from 459 W. Belden that showed Hunter Best in an alley, and Det. Brownlee obtained footage from a 7-11 that was later reviewed by Det Schmit and determined to not have any evidentiary value.

Footage gathered by Det. W. Johnson was inventoried and is reflected in the inventory list above.

Detective Schmit attends the forensic interview of child victim-2 at CCAC on 01 June at 9AM, and witnesses the interview with Cook County ASA Patrick Farrell. The interview concludes at 9:51AM.

This same day, Det. Schmit reviews the video footage from 459 W. Belden. The footage shows Hunter Best in an alley walking towards Cleveland Ave. around 2:14AM, and Schmit notes that this "appears to be the same male seen in the
[Redacted] alley footage". The 459 W. Belden footage is motion-activated, showing the male subject by the door of an apartment building, and he then disappears. Footage ends at 2:22AM.

Area Central catches a very helpful lead in the case when a woman who had a short-lived interaction with Best steps forward with her account of the interaction, AND jewelry that he gave her during that interaction. This woman saw the photos released by Area Central on the news, and upon hearing what he did, she becomes sickened and wants to help put him away.

Chicago-One will let Detective Schmit tell the rest of this woman's story about her interaction with Hunter Best.

Schmit continues working the case from here, gathering more video from one more location, and then he interviews a woman working in an apartment building who says he was there and he sexually harassed her after he was told to leave because he failed to prove he had legitimate reasons to be there.

Cleared by Arrest and Prosecution

Area Central Detectives applied for several warrants prior to the arrest of Hunter Best. On or around 09 July 2018 by the U.S. Marshall's Service after State of Illinois Arrest Warrant# CW0054452 was issued. Best was transported to the Marion County Jail in Indiana, and on 11 July 2018, Best waived extradition, allowing Detectives Schmit and Schur to transport him to the Area Central Detective Division. That arrest was made on 16 July 2018 at 3:45PM.

The court issued the arrest warrant after a Grand Jury issued an indictment against Hunter Best, also known as a True Bill. The True Bill listed 19 counts against Best. The Cook County State's Attorney's Felony Minute Sheet lists ten charges. The True Bill and Felony Minute Sheet are below.

Officers Huh - Star# 6926, and Kotlarz - Star# 16103, assigned to Chicago Police Special Investigations Unit 079, Beat 5751A, assisted in this arrest. The first court date was scheduled in Branch 66 on 17 July 2018. The Chicago Sun-Times reported on the arrest.

Nancy A. Hoffheimer was the Cook County ASA assigned to this case after CCSAO felony review approved charges. Hoffheimer is listed as having argued this case in Room 206 before Judge Erica L. Reddick

All of the source documents you see in-part, or in whole within this news article represent hundreds of thousands of dollars in manpower, investigative resources, and a litany of other things a city needs to be able to conduct in-depth felony violent crimes investigations. The source documents further show the public great insights into the psychology and criminal capabilities of a sexual offender who used alcohol to lower his inhibitions towards committing sex crimes against young children.

Most importantly, the source documents show the devastation done to two families and the child victims by way of the violation of the needed safety and security of their own bodies, in their own homes where ALL PEOPLE deserve to be safe, and free from violence.

Nancy Hoffheimer then does this

Kimberly Fox couldn't sign this plea agreement and 8 year sentence herself, she had to have Mary G. Innes sign. Eight years from now, these young ladies will once more need to worry about their safety. The sex abuse charges were taken off the table, meaning Hunter Best will never have to register as a sex offender. These young ladies will never know their offender's whereabouts. These young ladies will forever carry the trauma of what Hunter Best did in their homes on May 27th, 2018.

See the full Chicago Police investigative file on Hunter Best

See the Hunter Best Cook County States Attorney file